Posts Tagged ‘josh hamilton’

The AskROTObaseball Livecast is hosted by Dave Kerr and he welcomes a special guest each week. This week, Dave welcomed K.J. Hanna (@NYLivinCAMind). They talked all things Fantasy Baseball including several buy low candidates, including Jay Bruce, B.J. Upton, Josh Hamilton, and more! They also discuss Michael Saunders and play a game of pick ’em with players that play the same position.

Listen to
internet radio with AskROTObaseball Livecast on Blog Talk Radio



By David Kerr

Yesterday, I looked at three players, Justin Upton, Chris Davis, and Clay Buchholz, who have started the season by putting up quite gaudy numbers. Today, I want to look at two players who have done the opposite and whether you should buy, sell, or hold on to them. Let’s start in Los Angeles.

Josh Hamilton

Over 76 games dating back to last year’s All-Star break, Josh Hamilton is batting .247 with 16 home runs and 53 RBIs. Minus the average, those are solid power and run producing numbers. At one point early last season, Hamilton was the hottest hitter in baseball and it wasn’t even close. He hit a slump that saw his average drop over 100 points. This season he looks lost at the plate. On Wednesday night against Oakland, I watched him strikeout on three pitches with the bases loaded; strike three was a pitch way out of the zone that he reached for. He just seems uncomfortable. This is a player who is a career .299 hitter in April that also started 2012 batting .395 in that very month. Maybe it’s from jitters because he’s adjusting to a new team or maybe he’s lost a step. Whatever it is, I don’t think it will continue. Hamilton is a hitting machine and his price tag will never be lower this season than it is right now. I don’t think he’s going to put up the same type of power numbers that he put up while playing half of his games in Texas, but I do think hitting cleanup behind Mike Trout and Albert Pujols will soon pay dividends. If someone sours on Hamilton, find a way to acquire him. His track record is too good for him to all of a sudden be a notch above mediocre.

Recommendation: HOLD or BUY. Once he starts to hit (and he will,) the window will be closed.

Giancarlo Stanton

As one of my favorite players headed into this season, I think you probably already know what my recommendation will be. Let me tell you why. No one in the major leagues has a better chance to hit 45-50 home runs. I don’t care what the lineup around him looks like. I don’t care whether opposing teams will pitch around him (he already has a 8/11 walk-to-strikeout ratio.) When Stanton gets locked in, the ball will start flying. Just look at his ISO increase over the past three seasons. It has went from .248 (2010), to .275 (2011), to .318 (2012). I can’t stress enough the power that this guy possesses. Add that to the fact that he’s only 23, I can only imagine the numbers he’ll put up in the next 3-5 years. If you’re in a dynasty or keeper league, he’s one of the top five guys I’d look to acquire. Oh, and it certainly wouldn’t hurt to try to trade for him this year either in redraft leagues. If you already own him, don’t lose faith. The power numbers are coming… very soon.

Recommendation: HOLD or BUY!!

If you have a long form Fantasy Baseball question, please e-mail it to me at Also, you can click the button below to follow me on Twitter where I will give you instant answers to all of your Fantasy Baseball question’s!


By David Kerr

2013 Outfield Rankings

1. Mike Trout
2. Ryan Braun
3. Matt Kemp
4. Carlos Gonzalez
5. Andrew McCutchen
6. Giancarlo Stanton
7. Jason Heyward
8. Josh Hamilton
9. Jose Bautista
10. Justin Upton
11. Bryce Harper
12. Adam Jones
13. Matt Holliday
14. Jay Bruce
15. Jacoby Ellsbury
16. B.J. Upton
17. Yoenis Cespedes
18. Michael Bourn
19. Shin-Soo Choo
20. Austin Jackson
21. Allen Craig
22. Desmond Jennings
23. Ben Zobrist
24. Alex Rios
25. Mark Trumbo
26. Shane Victorino
27. Hunter Pence
28. Alex Gordon
29. Melky Cabrera
30. Carlos Beltran
31. Chris Davis
32. Andre Ethier
33. Michael Morse
34. Curtis Granderson
35. Ben Revere
36. Nelson Cruz
37. Dexter Fowler
38. Norichika Aoki
39. Josh Willingham
40. Josh Reddick
41. Jayson Werth
42. Martin Prado
43. Brett Gardner
44. Carlos Gomez
45. Nick Swisher
46. Angel Pagan
47. Cameron Maybin
48. Torii Hunter
49. Alfonso Soriano
50. Ichiro Suzuki
51. Coco Crisp
52. Carl Crawford
53. Alejandro De Aza
54. Michael Saunders
55. Michael Cuddyer
56. Dayan Viciedo
57. Carlos Quentin
58. Nick Markakis
59. Corey Hart
60. Jason Kubel
61. Emilio Bonifacio
62. Lorenzo Cain
63. Garrett Jones
64. Michael Brantley
65. Ryan Ludwick
66. Starling Marte
67. Adam Eaton
68. Delmon Young
69. Cody Ross
70. Jon Jay
71. Denard Span
72. Drew Stubbs
73. David Murphy
74. Juan Pierre
75. Matt Joyce
76. Colby Rasmus
77. Rajai Davis
78. Brandon Moss
79. Logan Morrison
80. Peter Bourjos
81. Lucas Duda
82. Tyler Colvin
83. Jeff Francoeur
84. Dominic Brown
85. Wil Myers
86. Chris Young
87. Will Venable
88. Aaron Hicks
89. Chris Carter
90. Travis Snider
91. Seth Smith
92. Darin Mastroianni
93. Gerardo Parra
94. Nate McClouth
95. Justin Ruggiano
96. Andy Dirks
97. Justin Maxwell
98. J.D. Martinez
99. Gregor Blanco
100. Jose Tabata

UPDATED 3/20/13:
Alex Gordon rises from #31 to #28.
Josh Willingham rises from #44 to #39.
Darin Mastroianni falls from #85 to #92.
Dominic Brown rises from #100 to #84.
Chris Carter makes the list for the first time at #89.
Jose Tabata makes the list for the first time at #100.
Brennan Boesch falls off the list.
John Mayberry falls off the list.

Overall Thoughts

Mike Trout or Ryan Braun. I’ve been debating between these two players most of the winter and seemingly go back and forth daily. With Braun, you’re looking at a six year veteran coming off back to back 30/30 seasons that has been a top three pick for the past three years. He hit a career high 41 home runs last season. Trout, finished second to Miguel Cabrera in MVP voting last season and likely would have won it had Cabrera not won the Triple Crown. He has an extremely high upside and put up his ridiculous stat line in just five months. In 2013, he will have a full season at the Major League level. News came out last week of Braun being linked to another PED case. You have to wonder whether he’s going to escape this one. Ryan Braun is the safe pick, but there are less question marks surrounding Mike Trout and for that reason, I have him ranked not only as the number one outfielder, but as you’ll see later this week, number one overall. Trout will regress some but at the end of the season he will have the statistics of a number one overall pick.

Coming into the 2012 season, Matt Kemp said his goal was a 50/50 season. He fell well short of that because of a hamstring injury. Naturally with a leg injury, he wasn’t able to run as much and only had nine steals on the season. That number will be back in the 30’s this year and so will his home run total. Kemp will go 30/30 again this year after just missing 40/40 in 2011.

I like Carlos Gonzalez over Andrew McCutchen. He is a more consistent player not to mention the fact that he plays half of his games at the hitter’s haven, Coors Field. What’s most alarming to me about McCutchen is the decline he’s experienced in the final two months. In 2011, he had a triple slash of .227/.336/.416. In 2012 it was more of the same, .253/.354/.435. It is worth noting that Gonzalez didn’t exactly have a great final two months either in 2012, but he did miss a lot of time to injury. I’m confident he stays healthy this season and puts up his best season since 2010. Don’t get me wrong, I like both players a lot, but my preference is Cargo.

Two young studs that I want this year are Giancarlo Stanton and Jason Heyward. If you want them, you’re going to have to use a second round pick because chances are they won’t be there after that. I can say with confidence that Stanton will hit over 40 homers this year. Not many players do that, so keep that in mind on draft day.

Now that B.J Upton and Justin Upton will be sharing the same outfield, I see big things from both of their bats. I think both men will be motivated in a big way and that will translate onto the field. Justin Upton has never really had that huge breakout season. His best season to date has been 2011, but then he regressed last year. He’s definitely been frustrating to own at points, but this will be his year. B.J. Upton is somewhat underrated in my book. He’s basically a lock for 30 steals and he has good power as well. Obviously his biggest knock is that he’s a .250 hitter. If you can handle his streaky bat and high strikeout totals, you’re looking at a 25/30 guy with upside for more. Keep in mind that he’s right in the middle of his prime at 28 years old.

I almost put Bryce Harper in my Top 10, but decided against it as I think that at age 20, he’ll have some growing pains. That isn’t to say that he won’t have a great season, I just don’t feel as though it will be better than someone more established such as Josh Hamilton or Jose Bautista. However, if I’m drafting in a Dynasty League, Harper is a top three pick, no question.

Adam Jones set a career high in both home runs and steals in 2012. It’d be nice to see him increase his steals into the 20-25 range, but if he can hit 30 homers, no one can really complain. Matt Holliday is as sure and steady as the come. He’ll have his usual .300/.380/.525 triple slash to go along with 25 plus homers. Is this the year Jay Bruce hits 40 homers? He’ll come close, but I think he’ll fall a few short. He’s increased his home run total every season in the Majors, but he really needs to cut down on the strikeouts which allow him to become prone to long slumps.

I absolutely love Shin-Soo Choo batting at the top of Cincinnati’s lineup. He’s an on-base machine with a nice blend of pop and speed. Hitting ahead of Brandon Phillips, Joey Votto, and Jay Bruce will push him over 100 runs for the first time in his career.

A player that can be somewhat frustrating yet still has very good numbers at the end of the year is Curtis Granderson. He has a swing made for Yankee Stadium as evident by his home run totals the past two seasons (41 and 43). What is disconcerting though is his decline in walks, stolen bases, and his overall average. His increase in strikeouts is concerning as well. All of these things tie together and it makes me skeptical to draft him. Even with 40 homer power, I’d rather let someone else grab Granderson. His numbers should be there at the end of the year, but I can’t say I’m a huge fan this year.

Desmond Jennings and Dexter Fowler are two players I see that will make positive strides this season. Alex Rios is someone that I’m incredulous about. It’s so hard to predict what he’s going to do because he’s been all over the map, seemingly every other season. If that actually is true, he could be in for a down year. I like Shane Victorino‘s prospects of playing in Fenway Park. Of course he will steal plenty of bags, but I see a slight uptick in his home run total too. He’s a solid player.

Ben Revere said he’s going to steal 60 bags in 2013. I don’t think he will, but he has a solid chance to swipe at least 50. The downside with Revere is that he has no power whatsoever. Keep that in mind on draft day.

Don’t forget about Jayson Werth. Some owners may forget about him because he missed a good chunk of the last season due to a wrist injury. He’s a 20/20 guy over a full, healthy season.

Carlos Gomez seemingly came out of nowhere last year and hit .278/.321/.488 with 14 homers and 26 steals… after the All-Star break. He could have a decent 2013, but don’t overpay for what he could do. He doesn’t walk enough and that isn’t likely to change. His power basically came out of nowhere, so don’t look for 19 homers again. I think 10-15 home runs is more than likely where he’ll end up, but the steals are definitely for real.

There is plenty of value to be found in later rounds for power. Players that fall into that category include: Dayan Viciedo, Carlos Quentin, Jason Kubel, Garrett Jones, and Colby Rasmus.

If you are looking for speed late, these players will provide you with great value: Emilio Bonifacio, Juan Pierre, Drew Stubbs, Rajai Davis, Will Venable, and Darin Mastroianni.

A few 2013 Sleeper picks: Michael Saunders, Dayan Viciedo, Lorenzo Cain, Adam Eaton, Jon Jay, Lucas Duda, Darin Mastroianni, J.D. Martinez, and John Mayberry.

A few 2013 Bust picks: Nelson Cruz, Carlos Gomez, Torii Hunter, Brandon Moss, Justin Ruggiano, and Nate McClouth.

Thanks for reading! Agree with my Rankings? Disagree? Please leave a comment. I’d love to interact with you. Look for my Top 100 Starting Pitcher Rankings tomorrow. Click below to follow me on Twitter!